Hutton Rudby Village Hall - History of Project and Public Consultation


Some factual answers to questions raised in the discussions over the precept

Is it all being done on behalf of the dramatic society?
Key features of the proposals require the Dramatic society to give up one night per week in the main hall, and to relinquish the storage room in the Leven room to return it to a lettable state. The phase 3 proposals will enable at least one room to be available during shows thus avoiding the current disruptions to other societies. The Stage is not being improved at all and there are no benefits to the dramatic society.

Why were the defects not covered by insurance?
The current insurance policy was taken out as a result of the recommendations of the YRCC which is a major advice centre for village halls. The new policy did not cover subsidence. Of the three structural surveys which have been done, only the first said it was due to tree roots. Subsequent experts, supported by further detailed inspection say it was simply due to the original design. An insurance claim would therefore have been unlikely to succeed.

What are the disability act requirements?
By October 2004 all parts of public buildings have to be accessible to all. Any lesser scheme than lowering the floor would not have provided unlimited access.

Isn't the scheme over ambitious?
The very nature of the structural and disability access problems require a significant project to correct. The additional work at the rear of the premises is partly to cure leakage and vandalism problems but also to provide modern facilities for the whole village. If the hall is to have a viable future it must meet the requirements of modern users.

Shouldn't the Village Hall Management Committee should be responsible to the Parish Council?
The Parish Council own the land in trust but a separate management Committee was established to achieve charitable status for the Hall. The Parish Council has a representative on it by right. As a result of the recent discussions the chairman of the PC is discussing increased representation for the PC on the Management Committee

Why does the disability access problem require the demolition of the whole?
It doesn't - none of the hall is being demolished- only the roof structure is being replaced,

Why do we need an additional room at the back?
The current hall suffers not only from its physical defects but also the fact that its income has been falling due to the difficulty in lettings at the same time as costs are going up because of increasing maintenance. Both issues have to be tackled and the third room at the rear is a key requirement for increasing lettabiity. It will provide an attractive room for new clubs and societies and there are already interested parties wanting to use it. The third room will mean that there will be less interruptions to regular users when shows are on and it will release the main hall for a larger activity one night per week. It will also be very attractive for general lettings such as children's parties, wedding receptions etc.

Isn't it going to compete with other venues in the Village?
While there is bound to be a little overlap, the refurbished hall will generally cater for larger events and activities for which there are no alternative venues.

Do we really need a theatre in a village this size?
The refurbished hall will not be a theatre any more than the existing hall. Work is not being carried out with that intention. The additional facilities being created, such as reasonable entrance foyer, additional toilets and additional storage, are all for the benefit of all users and to improve the general lettability.

What accountability does the Village Hall Management Committee have to the Parish Council?
The Land on which the Hall sits is owned in trust by the Parish Council who are the holding Trustees of the Hall. The Village Hall is a charity with the Hall management Committee as trustees. The constitution of the Hall requires that the Parish Council have a seat on the Management Committee. While, because of the Charitable status, the Parish Council can not 'control' the Hall Management Committee, discussions are in hand to increase the representation.

How much will the Village Hall pay back of the loan?
Discussions are in hand with the Parish Council. The amount paid back will depend on how successfully the income is increased but a target of £3500-£5000 is likely. In deciding the consequences of the loan, the Parish Council has had to take a worst-case scenario. The figures quoted for the maximum effect on precept assumed therefore that nothing would be paid back. In reality there will be sums paid back and this will reduce the Parish Precept.

Where are the accounts of the village hall made public?
Accounts are published annually at the annual general meeting of the Village Hall which all residents are entitled to attend. Notices of the annual general meeting are published in the SPAR and on notice boards. Back copies of the accounts are available through the web page and in a folder in the Post office.